This season
Pick your own Paula Reds start 4 September 2026. The farm says it has no dates yet for the later varieties and asks you to check back. Pick your own popcorn follows in the autumn.
Checked August 23, 2026
Barthel Fruit Farm has been at Mequon since 1840 and says so in its own strapline: "Offering Quality Produce, Pick Your Own and Family Fun Since 1840!" That makes it the oldest farm on this site by some distance.
The farm publishes pick-your-own prices and hours on its own site and updates them as varieties come in. It says plainly that it does not yet have dates for the later apples and asks you to check back.
For the popcorn it gives real instructions: "Pick the ears after the stalks are brown and dry, but before frost. The husks will be dry and the kernels hard."
Pro tip: Paula Red is an early apple that softens fast and cooks down to sauce almost on its own. Pick it the week it opens or not at all.
We list what we have confirmed. If something you need is not shown, it is worth calling the farm to check.
Our own assessment, scored the same way for every farm on the site, from what each farm publishes about itself. Not a visit, and not a public review score.